The data
This is an example, with made-up numbers for one month. Margin is the price minus the food cost of one plate.
| Item | Sold | Margin per plate | Total margin |
|---|---|---|---|
| Latte | 420 | 95 | 39,900 |
| Cappuccino | 300 | 90 | 27,000 |
| Cold coffee | 380 | 85 | 32,300 |
| Masala chai | 500 | 40 | 20,000 |
| Filter coffee | 260 | 60 | 15,600 |
| Veg sandwich | 210 | 70 | 14,700 |
| Paneer sandwich | 150 | 105 | 15,750 |
| Club sandwich | 60 | 120 | 7,200 |
| Brownie | 180 | 110 | 19,800 |
| Cheesecake | 50 | 140 | 7,000 |
| Banana bread | 40 | 65 | 2,600 |
| Garlic bread | 90 | 75 | 6,750 |
| Total | 2,640 | 208,600 |
The two lines
Popularity line. Twelve items share the sales, so an even share is 8.33 percent. A dish counts as popular at 70 percent of that, which is 5.83 percent. On 2,640 plates that is about 154 plates.
Margin line. Total margin divided by total plates: 208,600 divided by 2,640 is about 79 per plate.
The sorting
| Item | Popular (154 or more)? | Margin 79 or more? | Class |
|---|---|---|---|
| Latte | Yes | Yes | Star |
| Cappuccino | Yes | Yes | Star |
| Cold coffee | Yes | Yes | Star |
| Brownie | Yes | Yes | Star |
| Masala chai | Yes | No | Plowhorse |
| Filter coffee | Yes | No | Plowhorse |
| Veg sandwich | Yes | No | Plowhorse |
| Paneer sandwich | No (150) | Yes | Puzzle |
| Club sandwich | No | Yes | Puzzle |
| Cheesecake | No | Yes | Puzzle |
| Banana bread | No | No | Dog |
| Garlic bread | No | No | Dog |
Paneer sandwich misses the popularity line by four plates. That is a reminder: the lines are guides, not walls. Treat a dish near the line as a candidate for either group.
One action per group
Stars: protect them
The four stars bring in 119,000 of the 208,600 margin, about 57 percent. Do not change their recipe, size or price in a hurry. Keep them easy to find, and make sure you never run out of them.
Plowhorses: raise the price a little
Masala chai sells 500 cups at a margin of 40. It is the most popular item, and it earns the least per cup. Check the break-even for a price rise of 5.
| Item | Now | After a rise of 5 |
|---|---|---|
| Margin per cup | 40 | 45 |
| Cups sold | 500 | 475 (a fall of 5 percent) |
| Total margin | 20,000 | 21,375 |
Even if 5 percent of guests drop chai, the margin rises by 1,375. To find where it stops paying, divide 20,000 by 45. The answer is about 444 cups. The cafe could lose up to 56 cups, or 11 percent of chai sales, before the rise loses money. Watch the real number for a month.
Puzzles: help them sell
Cheesecake earns 140 a plate and sells 50. Make it easier to choose.
- Move it to the top of the dessert section.
- Name it clearly and describe it in a few plain words.
- Ask the cashier to suggest it with a coffee.
If cheesecake sales rise from 50 to 80, the extra margin is 30 times 140, or 4,200 a month.
Dogs: fix or drop
Banana bread and garlic bread sell 130 plates and earn 9,350, which is 4.5 percent of the margin. Run the test in how to decide which dish to remove. Garlic bread may be a side that helps other orders. Banana bread may be a candidate to drop.
Menu design: what to change on the page
- Put stars and puzzles in the places guests look first, such as the top of each section.
- Keep each section short, so the eye does not scan a wall of items.
- Write prices without long dotted lines to them. A plain number is enough.
- Describe puzzles in a short line. Do not oversell.
- Do not highlight every item. A highlight on everything highlights nothing.
Do it again
Run the sort every quarter. A dish moves between groups as prices and tastes change. Our menu engineering calculator does the sorting for you, and the menu engineering guide explains the method in full.
Common questions
What is menu engineering?
It sorts dishes by popularity and margin, so you know which to protect, reprice, promote or drop.
What is a plowhorse?
A popular dish with a low margin. A small price rise often helps.
What is a puzzle?
A dish with a high margin that few guests order. Better placement and suggestions can help it sell.
How often should I sort my menu?
About every quarter, or after a price change.
Are the popularity and margin lines fixed?
No. They are guides. A dish close to a line can go either way.