What is a star, puzzle, plowhorse and dog on a menu?
Star, puzzle, plowhorse and dog are the names for four dish groups, sorted by how popular and how profitable each dish is.
Also called: menu matrix, stars and dogs.
In plain words
A star is popular and profitable. A plowhorse is popular but earns little. A puzzle earns well but sells little. A dog is neither popular nor profitable.
Place each dish in one group, then act. Keep and show stars, nudge the price of plowhorses, promote puzzles and review dogs. The groups are a guide. Use your own judgement for dishes that complete the menu.
Example (made-up numbers): Butter chicken sells 400 plates and earns well: a star. A rarely ordered fish curry earns well: a puzzle.
What to watch for
Do not let the labels decide for you. A dog on paper may be a dish loyal guests love. Use the grid as a start for a conversation, then look at the dish in its context.
Go deeper
Read and use
- Read: Menu engineering: a worked example for a cafe
- Free tool: Menu engineering calculator